» copyright infringement

We believe in the copyright law. It’s been part of our laws since the Constitution was enacted. It’s there for a good reason: “to promote the progress of science and useful arts”. We advised and represent quite a few copyright owners. But every so often an over-zealous copyright owner goes too far. This could be one of those cases.

Charles Harris wrote a booklet called “How America Elects Her Presidents”. During the 2008 election, Oprah read aloud on her tv show questions that were based on material in the book. Apparently one of the questions was literally taken from Harris’ book: “Which one of our presidents weighed the most?”. [Answer: William Howard Taft at over 325 pounds]. Harris filed a lawsuit which requested millions of dollars in damages. Oprah filed a Motion to Dismiss the lawsuit and the judge agreed when he ruled that the allegedly infringed parts of his book were not original, and that Oprah’s recitation of the Taft fact, even if she did take it from Harris’ book, was not an actionable copyright infringement.

This is the second in the series:

“IP TIP #2: YOUR EMPLOYEES AND EX-EMPLOYEES MAY BE OUT TO GET YOU:

Do you have employees – or better yet disgruntled ex-employees – who might be tempted to turn you in for a million dollar reward? If so, the Business Software Alliance (“BSA”) has for several years been offering “rewards” of “up to” $1 million to anyone who turns in a business that is using software that is not properly licensed. [The BSA is a trade association made up of a few little companies like Apple, Microsoft, Symantec, Adobe and about 10 others].

And what does the BSA consider to be “not properly licensed”? Even if you purchased the software you are using legitimately, if you haven’t kept the proofs of purchase, receipts, etc., then as far as the BSA is concerned you are guilty of copyright infringement and subject to financial damages of up to $150,000 per infringement. The BSA also considers Microsoft Office to be five (5) separate programs, so if you have an unauthorized copy of Office the BSA claims you are liable for up to $750,000 in damages.

The BSA has been very successful in scaring businesses into paying huge sums of money to avoid a lawsuit. The irony is that sometimes the BSA extracts financial settlements from businesses that exceed what the damages would be if the business went to court and then worked out a court-supervised settlement with the BSA.

Forewarned is forearmed. We have helped several businesses negotiate resolutions of these kinds of disputes with the BSA.